Difference Between Gear Milling and Gear Hobbing | What is Gear Milling | CNCLATHING

2020.5.12

Gear is a vital component for rotating machines, with teeth mesh with another toothed part to transmit torque. How gears are made? Other than casting, forging, CNC machining can be applied to achieve the final shapes, dimensions, and surface finish of a gear. Here we introduce and compare two gear manufacturing methods – gear milling vs gear hobbing, what are the differences between them?

What is Gear Milling?

Gear milling is a common CNC milling operation and gear-cutting process of creating a gear. It can be operated either after or instead of forming processes including casting, forging, and extruding. Gears are usually made from metal, plastic, and wood. Many metal and plastic gears made by die-casting, injection molding, or additive manufacturing may not require cutting. For coarse-pitch gears, the generative gear milling technology can improve efficiency, expand the pitch capacity of the machine, reduce cutter cost, and may decrease the machining times.

What Cutter Used in Gear Milling?

The gear can be cut on a milling machine or jig grinder utilizing a gear cutter and indexing head or rotary table, the quantity of gear cutter is determined by tooth count of the gear required. Various types of cutters can be used for producing gears, for example, the rack shaper, with six to twelve teeth, straight and move in a direction tangent to the gear. The cutter has to move back to the beginning position for the new round cut. 

What is Gear Hobbing?

Gear hobbing is also a gear manufacturing method to cut teeth into the blank with a hob like an index hob and master hob on CNC gear hobbing machines. The hob and gear blank rotate at the same time in a mesh and cut the teeth by continuous cut, the rotating hob is fed inward until achieving proper depth, then work for the entire gear. Gear hobbing is a great choice for medium to high volume production runs. The hobbing features for gears including straight, helical, straight bevel, face, crowned, worm, and chamfering. 

What is the Difference Between Gear Milling and Gear Hobbing?

How to differentiate gear hobbing and gear milling?

1. The way gear teeth are produced

In gear milling, a single tooth spacing or gap between gear teeth will be created by a rotating multi-edge cutter at a time, the cross-section of generated teeth is similar to that of the cutter. In gear hobbing, the gear teeth are progressively produced by a series of cuts with a hob. So the hob cuts several gaps simultaneously.

2. Cutter

Gear milling uses a rotating form cutter, when each tooth space is cut, the cutter will return to the starting point and gear blanks are indexed for next cutting process; gear hobbing uses a helical hob cutter, the hob and the workpiece are both rotating constantly when the hob is fed across the face width of the blank.

3. The number of teeth cut in one time

Each cutter in gear milling is designed to cut a range of tooth numbers, while in gear hobbing, both the hob and gear blank rotate continuously as in two gears meshing until all teeth are cut. 

4. Price of tool

Generally, the gear milling cutting tool is cheaper than that of hobbing, but the productivity of gear hobbing may be higher.

5. Application

Gear hobbing is more often used for high production runs, and gear milling is a low production process.

6. Others

– Gear milling requires deburring

– Gear milling is often used when other generating processes are unavailable.